'American Idol': The show must go on

For the past two weeks, questionable song choices have led to surprising voting results. Two weeks ago, judges had to save Jessica Sanchez after she sang Jasmine Sullivan's Stuttering. Colton Dixon believed his decision to sing Lady Gaga resulted in his elimination last week.

So maybe Phillip Phillips and Elise Testone were courting fate when they picked, respectively, the Dave Matthews Band's The...